Old Homestead Steak House


CUISINE: Classic Steak House
AMBIENCE: Warm woods, soft fabrics
SIGNATURE DISH: Gotham Rib Steak 34 oz

The Old Homestead, a New York City institution, is one of the country’s oldest steakhouses and is known for serving the finest steaks in the Big Apple for nearly 150 years. With their second location in Atlantic City, guests can experience their trademarked domestically raised, hand-massaged Wagyu beef on both sides of the river.

Brothers and owners Marc and Greg Sherry believe in the adage “don’t mess with a good thing,” which is why the menu at their steakhouse in Atlantic City nearly mirrors the one in New York. And for good reason: "We haven't had an empty seat in quite a few years," Greg explained. Now visitors to Borgata have the chance to see why.

We made the list! Find out why our 20 oz. Prime Steakhouse Burger made Borgata's List of Top Burgers!

Hours

Group Dining

Dining Room

Fall Hours
Monday - Thursday: 5:30pm – 10:30pm
Friday: 5:30pm - 11pm
Saturday: 5pm – 11pm
Sunday: CLOSED

*closing hours subject to change reservations suggested

PROPER ATTIRE REQUIRED

Click Here

Learn more about group dining options available for parties of 15 or more.

Menu subject to change.

Download PDF Menus

Menu

APPETIZERS

10 ROASTED ONION SOUP
12 THE SOUP
24 SEARED SCALLOPS corn puree, lemon zest, chive oil
12 HEAVY CUT BACON Vermont fancy maple syrup
15 CLAMS CASINO bacon
12 FRIED CALAMARI basil Thai chili sauce
26 JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKE
24 BANG BANG SHRIMP tempura battered, pickled cucumber, chipotle mayo, anaheim pepper puree
20 MEATBALL 8 oz. Wagyu beef, fresh ricotta, gravy
24 COLOSSAL CRAB MEAT & ROCK SHRIMP COCKTAIL
8 CHEF'S SPECIAL BREAD PREPARATION

RAW BAR (priced per piece)

3 CLAMS ON THE HALF SHELL
4 EAST COAST OYSTERS
10 JUMBO SHRIMP
10 TUNA TARTARE garlic, ginger, soy, lime, cilantro
Market Price CAVIAR 1 OZ.

SALADS

13 STEAK HOUSE SALAD romaine, radicchio, tomatoes, gherkins, chopped egg, apple wood bacon, shaved reggiano, onion crunch, thousand island
13 CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD parmesan croutons
13 WEDGE OF ICEBERG LETTUCE crumbled blue cheese dressing, apple wood bacon
15 FRESH MOZZARELLA & ROASTED TOMATO fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil, aged balsamic vinegar
17 THE KITCHEN SINK mixed greens, salami, hearts of palm, chick peas, artichoke, red onion, cherry tomato, peppers, blue cheese, bacon, champagne basil mustard dressing

STEAKS, CHOPS & MORE

59 THE GOTHAM RIB STEAK 34 OZ. Old Homestead's Signature Steak
54 SHERRY BROTHERS NEW YORK SIRLOIN 18 OZ.
46 NEW YORK SIRLOIN 14 OZ
58 THE EMPIRE CUT OF PRIME RIB ON THE BONE
58 FILET MIGNON 18 OZ. bearnaise sauce
50 FILET MIGNON 10 OZ. hash brown, demi glaze
52 APPLEWOOD SMOKED BACON WRAPPED 10 OZ. FILET hash brown, demi glaze
115 PORTERHOUSE STEAK FOR TWO 48 OZ.
48 BABY RACK OF LAMB garlic mashed potato, demi glaze
36 20 OZ. PRIME STEAKHOUSE BURGER onion rings, chipotle ketchup, stone ground mustard
38 WHOLE FIRE ROASTED HERB CHICKEN
40 WILD CAUGHT SALMON carrot, cucumber, red onion, scallion, lemon cilantro vinaigrette, yum yum sauce
42 CHILEAN SEA BASS fried potato bundle, long beans, raisins, cashews, soy, cilantro, butter, lime, honey
40 SHRIMP SCAMPI lemon, garlic, basil, linguini
MARKET PRICE WHALE SIZE LOBSTERS
MARKET PRICE 10 OZ. MAIN LOBSTER TAIL
102 SURF AND TURF

ADD THESE CLASSICS

6 AU POIVRE
8 BLUE CHEESE MELT
26 COLOSSAL CRAB MEAT SAUTEED OR BAKED
28 OSCAR STYLE
28 CRAB AND BLUE CHEESE

SIDE OFFERINGS

14 SWEET POTATO MASHED with roasted walnuts and marshmallow
14 POTATO PANCAKES with applesauce and sour cream
14 GARLIC MASHED POTATO
14 FRESH CUT SEASONED FRIES
14 ONION RINGS
14 SALT AND PEPPER BRUSSELS SPROUTS
14 CREAMED OR SAUTÉED SPINACH
14 STEAMED OR SAUTÉED BROCCOLI
14 ASPARAGUS HOLLANDAISE
14 SAUTÉED BROCCOLI RABE
14 SAUTÉED ONIONS AND MUSHROOMS
14 LINGUINE with tomato and basil

SPECIALTY COCKTAIL MENU

14 ROSÉ SANGRIA Red Wine, Elderflower Syrup, Pomegranate Juice, Tomasello Blueberry Sparkling Wine
14 RUSSELL'S MINT JULEP Russell's Reserve 10yr Simple Syrup, Fresh Mint
14 MAPLE WHISKEY MOJITO Jim Beam Maple Whiskey Fresh Mint, Fresh Lime, Club Soda
14 TWISTED MARGARITA Cointreau Noir, Pattron Silver, Simple Syrup, Fresh Lime
14 BLACKBERRY BASIL WHISKEY SMASH Maker's Mark, Basil, Lemon, Blackberries
14 WALNUT CREEK Knob Creek, Nocello, Half and Half
40 MEXICAN LEMONADE Gran Patron Platinum Lemonade, Elderflower Syrup
40 MEXICAN MINT JULEP Gran Patron Platinum Elderflower Syrup, Fresh Mint
14 CAPTAIN’S COCONUT MOJITO Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, Malibu Rum, Fresh Lime, Fresh Mint, Pineapple Juice, 7up
14 MOSCOW MULE Belvedere Vodka, Ginger Beer, Fresh Lime Juice

DESSERTS

12 OLD HOMESTEAD'S FAMOUS CHEESECAKE
12 CRÈME BRULEE rich vanilla custard, caramelized sugar crust
14 DRUNKEN BANANA cinnamon buns, vanilla ice cream, brown sugar, rum
12 BIG FAT CHOCOLATE CAKE
14 GLAZED DOUGHNUT ICE CREAM SANDWICH coffee and vanilla ice cream, Valrhona chocolate sauce, butterscotch and chocolate shavings
12 FRESH MIXED BERRIES
12 BEN AND JERRY'S sampler
~ cherry garcia
~ coffee, coffee buzz buzz buzz
~ vanilla
12 WARM CHOCOLATE BROWNIE vanilla bean ice cream, warm butterscotch sauce, schlag
Menu subject to change.
View Fine Dining